Skin health is one of the most important parts of personal beauty. Hair dye, contacts and even diets can create big changes for one’s appearance. But the first thing people are going to notice is one’s skin.

Two new methods have recently appeared which can help restore a youthful appearance to one’s skin. In this article we’ll compare silk peels and microdermabrasion. Comparing every important point will determine which is the most effective treatment.

Difference in the Method of Action

silk peel facial

As skin ages it keeps dead and damaged cells on the surface level. Both procedures begin by removing this top layer of dead or damaged cells. What’s left behind is healthy and youthful skin.

They’re essentially a more powerful form of exfoliation. Typical exfoliants help the appearance of one’s skin. But they’re fairly crude in comparison to the microscopic precision of both silk peel and microdermabrasion.

The exfoliation phase is where microdermabrasion usually begins and ends. Silk peel adds an additional step which introduces topical solutions onto the treated area. Technicians usually tailor these solutions to the specific needs of a patient.

The silk peel vs microdermabrasion comparison has an easy winner here. Silk peel starts with the same general technique as microdermabrasion. But it then adds even more benefits on top of it.

Difference in Potential Discomfort

Removing an entire layer of skin sounds like a painful proposition. Anyone who’s tried other forms of exfoliation might have concerns over these two procedures. People often feel that standard exfoliation is a painful part of their routine. They’ll often assume that more advanced exfoliation will cause even more discomfort.

In fact, it’s the exact opposite. Both procedures work on a microscopic level. The more precise scale can specifically target dead skin cells. And dead skin cells are by definition unable to register pain or discomfort. Both silk peels and microdermabrasion just feel somewhat akin to a cat’s tongue.

A patient will feel the suction and movement of the dead skin cells as they’re collected. However, there is one point of difference in the silk peel vs microdermabrasion comparison. The silk peel’s topical compounds provide patients with a more soothing feeling after the procedure.

Difference in Length of Procedure

 

woman receiving microdermabrasion

Both procedures are noninvasive. By avoiding any form of surgical incision the timeframe is also kept quite compact. Any given procedure might come with additional complications. For example, a patient’s first treatment will generally be longer. This is simply due to the fact that staff will want to explain everything to the new patient.

But on average a standard microdermabrasion will take around thirty minutes. A silk peel typically takes much longer the first time around. A new patient will still want to have various things explained. But she’ll also need to have the topical solution tailored to her needs. A patient should expect to spend around sixty minutes for any following visits.

The silk peel vs microdermabrasion has a clear winner when looking at overall duration. The lowered complexity of microdermabrasion translates to a shorter timeframes.

Difference in Cost

Both procedures are surprisingly cost effective compared to surgical treatments. Most people also feel that the overall return on both is quite impressive for the cost. But no matter how comparable they might be, there’s always going to be a winner in price comparisons.

Price comparisons are made more difficult by geographical and economic variation. Different locations will typically offer different prices. But one can still look at overall averages to determine a winner.

The average price for microdermabrasion is around $175. The cost of a silk peel averages around $200. The overall price of the options are fairly similar. But the costs still provide an objective metric for a silk peel vs microdermabrasion comparison. Microdermabrasion is the clear winner, even if only by $25.

Risk factors

People often focus on beauty when thinking about their skin. But skin serves an important protective function for the human body. Some people have expressed concerns over silk peel and microdermabrasion’s potential to increase any existing risk factors a patient might possess.

The largest concern involved the combination of these procedures and retinoid based treatments. Retinoids are a common method to treat wrinkles and sun damage. It’s safe to assume a high level of overlap between people using retinoids and those interested in dermabrasive techniques.

Researchers finally put people’s minds at ease through a detailed study. Their study proved that microdermabrasion posed little additional risk in combination with retinoids. The combination created slightly more side effects. But these were all described as transitive and mild. And the benefits of each treatment built upon each other. As such there are no major risk factors for microdermabrasion.

The individualized nature of silk peels makes it more difficult to study. But given the similarity in technique it’s safe to assume that they’re equivalent in risk factors. This creates a tie in the silk peel vs microdermabrasion comparison for risk factors.

So What’s the Overall Effectiveness?

woman photographed before and after a silk peel

Before and after silk peel.

Both procedures remove dead skin cells. As such, their overall effectiveness is fairly similar. Of course there’s some minor variations which one should consider. A silk peel uses a custom proprietary material for the exfoliation phase. While microdermabrasion has been standardized to use well known abrasive materials.

But in general the two procedures provide similar results after the initial exfoliation. The silk peel vs microdermabrasion has a clear winner here though. Both procedures have the same mechanical base.

But a silk peel adds in specially tailored solutions in order to increase effectiveness. This would mean a clear win for the silk peel even if the solutions provided minimal additional benefits. And many people find the benefits to be far more than minimal.

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, one can easily see a clear winner. Both procedures are quite effective. They also use a very similar method of microscopic exfoliation. This similarity also provides an easy win for the silk peel.

A silk peel treatment provides the same benefits as microdermabrasion. But it provides specially tailored topical solutions on top of that exfoliant base. Microdermabrasion is slightly cheaper and slightly faster. But the difference in these two factors isn’t enough. Silk peel is the best option for most but you should always consult your dermatologist to establish if it’s the right choice for you too.

Image Source: 1, 2, 3